Nelson Peltz lost the Disney proxy war. He still scored a $300 million return in defeat

• Activist investor Nelson Peltz lost a long proxy war against Disney CEO Bob Iger.
• The Wall Street Journal reported that Peltz’s hedge fund made around $300 million in profits from the battle.
• It represents a win for Peltz, even in defeat.

The proxy war between Disney and billionaire activist investor Nelson Peltz is over.

Disney CEO Bob Iger gets to maintain control of the board, the company, as Iger says, can now focus on making better content, and Peltz … books a $300 million return?

According to The Wall Street Journal, Peltz’s hedge fund Trian Partners may have profited about $300 million by waging a 16-month proxy battle against Disney, citing anonymous sources familiar with the matter.

Last February, Bloomberg reported that Trian made about $154 million in paper profit after buying 9.4 million shares of Disney. Around that time, Disney’s stock experienced a surge after Iger announced a restructuring plan that would cut 7,000 employees and save the company about $5.5 billion.

Now, The Journal reported that Peltz’s firm is expected to have made a total of around $300 million — a 40% return on its investment — after accounting for the $25 million Trian is estimated to have spent on the proxy war.

So even though Peltz lost the long proxy fight against Disney and won't gain the two new board seats he was hoping for, is this still a win for the activist investor?

Peltz appears to be spinning it that way based on the comment he made after the shareholders' decision on Wednesday.

"Since we reengaged with the company last October, Disney's stock is up about 50% and is the Dow's best performer here to date," he said.

But as The Journal noted, Trian's $300-million consolation prize isn't large compared to the firm's vast assets worth $10 billion under management.

James Park, a corporate law expert from the University of California, Los Angeles, told Business Insider that it's clear that Peltz would have preferred to win the seats he was seeking, given the amount of time and energy he spent on his activism. After all, Peltz waged two separate proxy battles against Disney in less than two years.

"That effort could have been spent on other investments or campaigns," Park said. "There are easier ways to make money than activism and so Peltz must be disappointed by the outcome."

"It is a lot of Sound and Fury signifying nothing," he said.

A spokesperson for Trian Partners did not respond to a request for comment.